Modal Verbs

(A) What they are

The modal verbs: must, can, could, may, might, will, would, shall, should, ought to.

They never change form — no -s, -ing, or -ed. “She must study hard,” never “She musts study hard.” (For the past idea, “had to” fills in: “She had to study hard.”)

They’re followed by the base verb, no “to” — “Tom may be late to the lecture today.” (Compare “have to,” which does take “to”: “You have to see a doctor. You look terribly ill.”)

For a past meaning, use the modal + have + past participle — “You shouldn’t have left the door unlocked. That was your mistake.” “Tom must have been very angry yesterday.”

They double as helping verbs for questions and negatives — “Can I talk to Mr. Hamdy?” “Sorry, he can’t take phone calls now.” “Should we come every day at 7 in the morning?”

The actual time — past, present, future — comes from context, not the modal’s form. “This is his car. He must be at home now” (present). “His car isn’t here. He must have left” (past). “They may come back tomorrow” (future).

Modals carry meanings like obligation, necessity, certainty, permission, prediction, requests, prohibition (must, have to, should, can, will, may) and suggestions, lack of necessity, possibility, ability, offers, speculation, advice (shall, needn’t, can, could, may, might, would).

And one modal can carry several different meanings depending on context — “You must have been tired at the end of the race” (speculation); “You must study harder for the exam” (obligation); “You mustn’t exceed the speed limit” (prohibition).

(B) What they’re used for

Ability (can, could) — “Tom can play the guitar perfectly.” “I could run fast when I was young.” Note: for a specific past failure, “couldn’t” covers it — “I couldn’t know his home address” (not “wasn’t able to know”). And “able to” can stand in for “can” — “She is able to paint the house on her own.”

Obligation and necessity (must, have to) — “You must listen carefully to your teacher.” “You have to be at the airport at 9 o’clock.” “You are obliged to respect your teachers” becomes “You must respect your teachers.” “It’s important for me to get up at six daily” becomes “I have to get up at six every day.” For the past: “It was necessary for my father to travel yesterday” becomes “My father had to travel yesterday.”

Lack of necessity (needn’t, don’t have to) — “You don’t have to answer all the questions.” “You needn’t answer all the questions.” For something that turned out unnecessary in the past: “The store is locked today. You needn’t have come.” “It wasn’t necessary for you to bring all the books” becomes “You needn’t have brought all the books.”

Prohibition (mustn’t, can’t) — “You mustn’t drive over 100 km/h.” “You can’t use the front door. It’s for the staff members only.” “You aren’t allowed to go in because you are under 18” becomes “You can’t go in because you are under 18.” “It is very important not to forget your medicine” becomes “You mustn’t forget your medicine.”

Speculation (must, can’t) — “It is Sunday. He must be at home.” “His car isn’t in the garage. He can’t be at home.” For a past guess: “Tom didn’t come to school. He must have been ill.” “I didn’t see you there. You can’t have come.” “I’m sure your daughter is very nice to you” becomes “Your daughter must be very nice to you.” “I am sure you didn’t paint the house yourself” becomes “You can’t have painted the house yourself.”

Future prediction (will, might, may) — “will” signals certainty: “I think I will go to the party tomorrow.” “may”/”might” signal uncertainty: “I am not sure yet. I may go to Ireland in the summer.” “Take an umbrella with you. It might rain later.” “It’s likely to rain this afternoon” becomes “It might rain this afternoon.”

Possibility (can, could, may, might) — “Bob may be in his office.” “Bob might be having lunch.” “The roads could get very busy tomorrow because of the match.” “Perhaps Tom is in his office” becomes “Tom may be in his office.” “She didn’t answer the phone. Perhaps she was asleep” becomes “She might have been asleep.” “She may come late” is equivalent to “She is likely to come late.”

Permission (can, could, may, might I...?) — “Can I use your pen for a minute?” “Could I use your pen for a minute?” “May I come in?” “Mum says I can’t go out with friends” (= “Mum doesn’t allow me to go out with my friends” / “Mum doesn’t let me go out with my friends”). “Do you mind if I use your pen for a minute?” becomes “Could I use your pen for a minute?”

Making suggestions (shall, can, could, how about?, what about?, let’s, why don’t we?) — “Shall we go to the theatre tomorrow?” is equivalent to “How about going to the theatre tomorrow?” “We could go to the cinema this weekend” is equivalent to “Why don’t we go to the cinema this weekend?”

Giving advice (should, ought to) — “You should / ought to go to school early” (general advice). “You’d better go early or you’ll miss the train” (specific situation). “If I were you, I’d find another job” becomes “You should find another job.” “You should see a doctor for that headache” can also be “You’d better see a doctor for that headache.”

Making requests (can, could, will, would you...?) — “Will you get me some water please?” “Would you type these letters for me, please?” “Can you give me a hand with these boxes, please?”

Making offers (would you like, shall I...?) — “You look tired. I will do the washing up for you” becomes “You look tired. Shall I do the washing up for you?” — also expressible as “Would you like me to do the washing up for you?” or “Do you want me to do the washing up for you?”